Skip to content Skip to search

Republish This Story

* Please read before republishing *

We’re happy to make this story available to republish for free under an Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives Creative Commons license as long as you follow our republishing guidelines, which require that you credit The 19th and retain our pixel. See our full guidelines for more information.

To republish, simply copy the HTML at right, which includes our tracking pixel, all paragraph styles and hyperlinks, the author byline and credit to The 19th. Have questions? Please email [email protected].

— The Editors

Loading...

Modal Gallery

/
Sign up for our newsletter

Menu

  • Our Mission
  • Our Team
  • Latest Stories
  • Search
  • Upcoming Events
  • Contact Us
  • Newsletter
  • Donate
  • Work With Us
  • Fellowships
    • From the Collection

      Changing Child Care

      Illustration of a woman feeding a baby a bottle
      • Washington, D.C., offers financial relief to local child care workers

        Orion Rummler · September 20
      • As climate change worsens hurricane season in Louisiana, doulas are ensuring parents can safely feed their babies

        Jessica Kutz · May 5
      • Supreme Court Justice Samuel Alito argued abortion isn’t an economic issue. But is that true?

        Chabeli Carrazana · May 4
    • From the Collection

      Next-Gen GOP

      Illustration of a woman riding an elephant
      • Mayra Flores’ victory set a record for women in Congress. It also reflects the growing visibility of Republican Latinas

        Candice Norwood · June 21
      • A banner year for Republican women

        Amanda Becker · November 11
      • Republican women could double representation in the U.S. House

        Amanda Becker · November 4
    • From the Collection

      On The Rise

      Illustration of three women marching
      • Can Cheri Beasley build a winning coalition in North Carolina?

        Candice Norwood · October 11
      • Los Angeles has never elected a woman mayor. Karen Bass hopes to change that.

        Nadra Nittle · September 8
      • Judge J. Michelle Childs is confirmed to D.C. appeals court

        Candice Norwood · July 20
    • From the Collection

      Pandemic Within a Pandemic

      Illustration of four people marching for Black Lives Matter with coronavirus as the backdrop
      • The 19th Explains: Why the nursing shortage isn’t going away anytime soon

        Mariel Padilla · September 23
      • Some LGBTQ+ people worry that the COVID-19 vaccine will affect HIV medication. It won’t.

        Orion Rummler · November 23
      • Why are more men dying from COVID? It’s a complicated story of nature vs. nurture, researchers say

        Mariel Padilla · September 22
    • From the Collection

      Portraits of a Pandemic

      Illustration of a woman wearing a mask and holding up the coronavirus
      • For family caregivers, COVID is a mental health crisis in the making

        Shefali Luthra · October 8
      • A new database tracks COVID-19’s effects on sex and gender

        Shefali Luthra · September 15
      • Pregnant in a pandemic: The 'perfect storm for a crisis'

        Shefali Luthra · August 25
    • From the Collection

      The 19th Explains

      People walking from many articles to one article where they can get the context they need on an issue.
      • The 19th Explains: What we know about Brittney Griner’s case and what it took to get her home

        Candice Norwood, Katherine Gilyard · December 8
      • The 19th Explains: Why the Respect for Marriage Act doesn’t codify same-sex marriage rights

        Kate Sosin · December 8
      • The 19th Explains: Why baby formula is still hard to find months after the shortage

        Mariel Padilla · December 1
    • From the Collection

      The Electability Myth

      Illustration of three women speaking at podiums
      • Mayra Flores’ victory set a record for women in Congress. It also reflects the growing visibility of Republican Latinas

        Candice Norwood · June 21
      • Stepping in after tragedy: How political wives became widow lawmakers

        Mariel Padilla · May 24
      • Do term limits help women candidates? New York could be a new testing ground

        Barbara Rodriguez · January 11
    • From the Collection

      The Impact of Aging

      A number of older people walking down a path of information.
      • From ballroom dancing to bloodshed, the older AAPI community grapples with gun control

        Nadra Nittle, Mariel Padilla · January 27
      • 'I'm planning on working until the day I die': Older women voters are worried about the future

        Mariel Padilla · June 3
      • Climate change is forcing care workers to act as first responders

        Jessica Kutz · May 31
    • From the Collection

      Voting Rights

      A series of hands reaching for ballots.
      • Election workers believe in our system — and want everyone else to, too

        Barbara Rodriguez, Jennifer Gerson · November 8
      • Voter ID laws stand between transgender people, women and the ballot box

        Barbara Rodriguez · October 14
      • Emily’s List expands focus on diverse candidates and voting rights ahead of midterm elections

        Errin Haines · August 30

    View all collections

  • Explore by Topic

    • 19th Polling
    • Abortion
    • Business & Economy
    • Caregiving
    • Coronavirus
    • Education
    • Election 2020
    • Election 2022
    • Environment & Climate
    • Health
    • Immigration
    • Inside The 19th
    • Justice
    • LGBTQ+
    • Politics
    • Press Release
    • Race
    • Sports
    • Technology

    View All Topics

Home
  • Our Mission
  • Our Team
  • Latest Stories
  • Search
  • Upcoming Events
  • Contact Us
  • Newsletter
  • Donate
  • Work With Us
  • Fellowships

We’re an independent, nonprofit newsroom reporting on gender, politics and policy. Read our story.

The 19th News(letter)

News from reporters who represent you and your communities.

You have been subscribed!

Submitting...

Uh-oh! Something went wrong. Please try again later.

Become a member

The 19th thanks our sponsors. Become one.

#FreeBritney protesters demonstrate in Los Angeles with a cardboard cutout of Britney Spears.
Britney Spears' plea to be released from her conservatorship struck a chord with many Americans, who have since gathered and spoken out in her support. (Photo by Rich Fury/Getty Images)

Health

After Britney Spears’ plea, a new look at conservatorship

The pop star’s plight drew headlines, but many people in conservatorships have even fewer options.

Jennifer Gerson

Reporter

Jennifer Gerson headshot

Published

2021-07-01 17:12
5:12
July 1, 2021
pm

Share

  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • Email

The continuing proceedings surrounding Britney Spears’ conservatorship case mean that once again, more Americans are learning about the very idea of conservatorship itself, and the ways it is applied to those with mental illness or disability. 

The latest developments came this week when Judge Brenda Penny signed off on documents approving Bessemer Trust, a financial company, to the role of co-conservator of Spears, while also maintaining her father, Jamie Spears, as the pop icon’s other co-conservator. These latest legal proceedings are not connected to Spears’ recent testimony asking for her conservatorship to end, but do re-affirm her father in his conservator role even after that testimony. Bessemer Trust asked on Thursday to be released from the arrangement, citing Spears’ publicized plea.

The case has drawn widespread attention, but for advocates who have worked with the 1.3 million Americans living under conservatorship, it is in some ways “not surprising and frustrating” that Spears’ testimony has been viewed as an anomaly.

The 19th thanks our sponsors. Become one.

“People are saying, ‘This is terrible that Britney is subjected to this.’ But I would say, ‘It’s rather terrible that we subject a lot of the people we subject to this,’” Kathy Flaherty, the executive director of the Connecticut Legal Rights Project (CLRP) — which provides legal assistance for people who are eligible for state-run mental health services in Connecticut, including many people in in-patient, state-run psychiatric facilities. 

“I think people have to really look at how we allow the law to control people’s lives,” she added.

Flaherty believes that inherent in this conversation is a seemingly contradictory belief about how many Americans view government intervention in the lives of its citizens generally versus how they believe that same philosophy extends to those with mental illness. 

Stories by experienced reporters you can trust and relate to.

Delivered directly to your inbox every weekday.

You have been subscribed!

Submitting…

Uh-oh! Something went wrong. Please try again later.

“So many people are in a rush to claim that the government shouldn’t do this or that or anything that would interfere with people’s lives and freedoms, but it seems to be OK to do when we’re talking about a person with a disability,” she said. And Flaherty said the situation seems to escalate when discussing mental health specifically: “There, you’re forcing people into treatment, forcing people to be admitted to a hospital, and keeping someone locked up in there.”

For Flaherty, the issue is personal. During her first year of law school, she was civilly committed and held in an in-patient facility for two months. “I was injected with medication I didn’t want, secluded, sedated, restrained. None of that is fun,” Flaherty said. “The fact that I still think about all of this 30 years later — it doesn’t go away. It provides motivation for a career, but it doesn’t go away.”

Flaherty said she hopes that Spears’ case brings to light that in many cases, lawyers may not be fully attentive to their clients’ wishes. 

She stressed that while sometimes a conservatorship may be the “the only way to address what’s going on” in regards to a person with mental illness or disability, there are other mechanisms that should often be explored first. Flaherty noted that people can draw up legal documents outlining advance directives for their health care, appointing health care representatives and creating agreements showing that you have a team to help support you in making decisions. 

“These things maximize people’s ability to control their own lives,” she said. “And if you’re taking them away, they should be reviewed. And if they’re not necessary to begin with, then they shouldn’t be kept in place.”

One thing that is incredibly unique about Spears’ case within the context of conservatorship cases at large is how much money her estate encompasses. As a result, Flaherty said, it is important to remember that “people are getting paid in Britney Spears’ case, and whenever someone is getting paid, look at what people are incentivized to do.” 

The majority of Flaherty’s clients do not have such wealth. Flaherty says court-appointed conservators often take on a large number of cases since they receive a flat fee for each of these from the court. The consequences of those high caseloads, she suggested, could be adverse for the people in conservatorship like the clients she serves. 

“Depending on how cynical I feel on a given day, I think they’re working exactly as they’re intended because they are benefitting people who already have power,” Flaherty said. 

  • More from The 19th
    #FreeBritney activists protest outside the courthouse in Los Angeles.
  • Britney Spears lost her reproductive freedom. Tragically, her case is not unique.
  • ‘We stand in solidarity’: Reproductive justice and disability rights advocates react to Britney Spears’ forced IUD

Sometimes, these lawyers also fail to remember what it means to work for a client who has had a conservatorship petition filed against them. 

“Their job is to be a zealous advocate for that person’s expressed preferences,” she said. “It’s not their job to be their guardian and look out for their best interest, but to advocate for what the client wants and let the judge make his or her decision” about whether the burden of proof has been met for implementing a conservatorship. 

Alex Barnard, an assistant professor of sociology at New York University whose research focuses on mental health policy and inequities — and specifically around mental health conservatorships in California, where the pop star lives — agreed that Spears’ case was unusual, especially for the state. In California, he said, conservatorships aren’t typically applied until a person “has done nothing less than almost dying.” Typically, a mental health conservatorship — which is what was originally applied to Spears in 2008 before she was transitioned to a conservatorship through the probate court system — is granted only after it is proven that a person cannot provide food, clothing or shelter for themselves. 

“If you can occasionally figure out how to get to a soup kitchen, that meets the need for food,” he said. “If you can figure out a place to sleep under the highway, that meets the standard for shelter. We typically wait a very, very long time and for people to be in a very bad place to be put into conservatorships.”

Barnard said he was worried that Spears’ case “distorts” this reality that most Californians are facing when it takes so much for many people with disabilities to qualify for any kind of social net services, even if that is only under the auspices of conservatorship.

Even more crucial, Barnard said, is to recognize conservatorships other than Spears’ reflect how the “the health system is failing” those who are struggling and not the legal system. Through this lens, it’s also apparent how many, many people are really struggling.

“You could add more legal protections to make it harder to get conservatorships granted or easier for conservatorships to be granted, but all that really points to is not having a robust mental health system offering intense and voluntary services,” he said. “Whether that’s through hospitals or residential treatment, we need to think about this on the front end about how to best help people so that the only option isn’t to curtail their rights and throw them in a locked facility.”

Unlike in Spears’ case, economic status is typically the largest barrier to getting these kinds of front-end services that can circumvent the need for conservatorship altogether,  Barnard said. Those with means have the ability to pay for weekly psychiatric therapy out of pocket — psychiatry is less likely to accept insurance than other types of medicine — and have a work schedule that allows for making weekly sessions and reliable transportation to get to and from those appointments. 

“But a poor person on Medicaid with schizophrenia is going to have to navigate an extremely convoluted system that will have you waiting months to see a psychiatrist even once,” he said. 

Further compounding the issue is the way that race intersects with economics; Barnard pointed to research suggesting that people of color are less likely to get a call back from a mental health professional after first initiating contact for care. Additionally, involuntary mental health holds are commonly instigated by police who get called in and make the call that someone is dangerous to themself or others, and “there are huge racial disparities in this” form of policing. 

When discussing conservatorships, both Barnard and Flaherty mentioned that most often they heard about cases involving Black men, partly because of the systemic issues that flagged them for oversight. But there is no national database on people placed in such arrangements.

Barnard said he is concerned that absent Britney Spears, “a lot of people on mental health conservatorships in California are sadly people who no one cares about.” 

“The Britney case is simple,” Barnard said. “She should get off of [her conservatorship] and would probably be OK after that. She might make some decisions that are bad, but she is quite competent to live her life and make these decisions.” 

But for many people in California specifically who find themselves in conservatorships, the situation is much more complicated, Barnard said. 

“A lot of people on conservatorships were homeless prior to their conservatorship. So are they going to be homeless after their conservatorship? If we sever them from the court, what services will they have left?” 

He emphasized that a “focus on intensive voluntary outpatient services plus permanent supportive housing integrated into the community” could be a solution for many. But he also noted that some people currently on conservatorships may still need something more structured than that. 

“A lot of people are currently in locked facilities, so what are the step-down programs that would move someone towards independence in a more deliberate fashion than just saying, ‘We will put you in this apartment and offer you services but you can say no to them.’ Some people may thrive, but some people may struggle.”

The ironic thing remains that all of these interventions are seemingly designed to help those already, in some way, struggling or marginalized, yet too often set them up for even greater challenges afterwards while failing to meaningfully intervene in their struggles before. 

“I don’t think people think about the impact of things we do to people ‘for their own good’ and that these things can be really harmful,” Flaherty said. “When Britney Spears expressed that she felt like her lawyer wasn’t listening to her and she wasn’t sure what was going on with her own case, that’s not uncommon. A lot of times, clients tell us, ‘You’re the first person who ever listened to me.’”

Share

  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • Email

Help sustain what we started

Your monthly investment is critical to our sustainability as a nonprofit newsroom.

Donate Today

Become a member

Up Next

Tampons tax illustration.

Politics

Three states have killed the ‘tampon tax,’ but advocates want more

Bans on taxing menstrual products are growing around the country. Advocates are cheering the victories, but they want legislatures to take faster action because of the ongoing effects of the pandemic.

Read the Story

The 19th
The 19th is a 501(c)(3) tax-exempt organization. Our stories are free to republish in accordance with these guidelines.

  • Donate
  • Newsletter
  • Events
  • Search
  • Jobs
  • Fellowships
  • Contact Us
  • About Us
  • Community Guidelines
  • Membership
  • Membership FAQ
  • Major Gifts
  • Sponsorship
  • Privacy
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • Instagram