Skip to content Skip to search

Republish This Story

* Please read before republishing *

We’re happy to make this story available to republish for free under an Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives Creative Commons license as long as you follow our republishing guidelines, which require that you credit The 19th and retain our pixel. See our full guidelines for more information.

To republish, simply copy the HTML at right, which includes our tracking pixel, all paragraph styles and hyperlinks, the author byline and credit to The 19th. Have questions? Please email [email protected].

— The Editors

Loading...

Modal Gallery

/

Menu

  • Our Mission
  • Our Team
  • Latest Stories
  • Search
  • Upcoming Events
  • Contact Us
  • Newsletter
  • Donate
  • Work With Us
  • Fellowships
    • From the Collection

      Changing Child Care

      Illustration of a woman feeding a baby a bottle
      • The full PUMP Act is now in effect. Here’s what it does for lactating parents.

        Chabeli Carrazana · April 28
      • 1 in 4 parents report being fired for work interruptions due to child care breakdowns

        Chabeli Carrazana · February 2
      • Washington, D.C., offers financial relief to local child care workers

        Orion Rummler · September 20
    • From the Collection

      Next-Gen GOP

      Illustration of a woman riding an elephant
      • Mayra Flores’ victory set a record for women in Congress. It also reflects the growing visibility of Republican Latinas

        Candice Norwood · June 21
      • A banner year for Republican women

        Amanda Becker · November 11
      • Republican women could double representation in the U.S. House

        Amanda Becker · November 4
    • From the Collection

      On The Rise

      Illustration of three women marching
      • This Delaware candidate could be the first transgender member of Congress

        Orion Rummler · June 26
      • Can Cheri Beasley build a winning coalition in North Carolina?

        Candice Norwood · October 11
      • Los Angeles has never elected a woman mayor. Karen Bass hopes to change that.

        Nadra Nittle · September 8
    • From the Collection

      Pandemic Within a Pandemic

      Illustration of four people marching for Black Lives Matter with coronavirus as the backdrop
      • Some LGBTQ+ people worry that the COVID-19 vaccine will affect HIV medication. It won’t.

        Orion Rummler · November 23
      • Why are more men dying from COVID? It’s a complicated story of nature vs. nurture, researchers say

        Mariel Padilla · September 22
      • Few incarcerated women were released during COVID. The ones who remain have struggled.

        Candice Norwood · August 17
    • From the Collection

      Portraits of a Pandemic

      Illustration of a woman wearing a mask and holding up the coronavirus
      • For family caregivers, COVID is a mental health crisis in the making

        Shefali Luthra · October 8
      • A new database tracks COVID-19’s effects on sex and gender

        Shefali Luthra · September 15
      • Pregnant in a pandemic: The 'perfect storm for a crisis'

        Shefali Luthra · August 25
    • From the Collection

      The 19th Explains

      People walking from many articles to one article where they can get the context they need on an issue.
      • The 19th Explains: What are 'late-term abortions' — and why are politicians talking about them? 

        Mel Leonor Barclay, Shefali Luthra · August 21
      • The 19th Explains: Why child marriage is still legal in 80% of U.S. states

        Mariel Padilla · July 5
      • The 19th Explains: The Supreme Court’s decision in the LGBTQ+ 303 Creative case

        Kate Sosin · June 30
    • From the Collection

      The Electability Myth

      Illustration of three women speaking at podiums
      • Mayra Flores’ victory set a record for women in Congress. It also reflects the growing visibility of Republican Latinas

        Candice Norwood · June 21
      • Stepping in after tragedy: How political wives became widow lawmakers

        Mariel Padilla · May 24
      • Do term limits help women candidates? New York could be a new testing ground

        Barbara Rodriguez · January 11
    • From the Collection

      The Impact of Aging

      A number of older people walking down a path of information.
      • From ballroom dancing to bloodshed, the older AAPI community grapples with gun control

        Nadra Nittle, Mariel Padilla · January 27
      • 'I'm planning on working until the day I die': Older women voters are worried about the future

        Mariel Padilla · June 3
      • Climate change is forcing care workers to act as first responders

        Jessica Kutz · May 31
    • From the Collection

      The State of Our Nation

      • States passing abortion bans reflect what only a small minority of their constituents actually want

        Jasmine Mithani · October 24
    • From the Collection

      Voting Rights

      A series of hands reaching for ballots.
      • Voting organizers are breathing ‘a deep sigh of relief’ over Supreme Court rulings on elections — for now

        Barbara Rodriguez · July 6
      • Ranked-choice voting is gaining momentum. So are efforts to stop it.

        Barbara Rodriguez · April 24
      • Connecticut voters approved early voting. Here’s how their new secretary of state wants to make it happen.

        Barbara Rodriguez · February 13

    View all collections

  • Explore by Topic

    • 19th Polling
    • Abortion
    • Business & Economy
    • Caregiving
    • Coronavirus
    • Education
    • Election 2020
    • Election 2022
    • Election 2024
    • Environment & Climate
    • Health
    • Immigration
    • Inside The 19th
    • Justice
    • LGBTQ+
    • Military
    • Politics
    • Press Release
    • Race
    • Sports
    • Technology

    View All Topics

Home
  • Our Mission
  • Our Team
  • Latest Stories
  • Search
  • Upcoming Events
  • Contact Us
  • Newsletter
  • Donate
  • Work With Us
  • Fellowships

We’re an independent, nonprofit newsroom reporting on gender, politics and policy. Read our story.

The 19th News(letter)

News that represents you, in your inbox every weekday.

You have been subscribed!

Please complete the following CAPTCHA to be confirmed. If you have any difficulty, contact [email protected] for help.

Submitting...

Uh-oh! Something went wrong. Please email [email protected] to subscribe.

Become a member

The 19th thanks our sponsors. Become one.

People hold up signs as they have their picture taken at a photo booth during a
People hold up signs as they have their picture taken at a photo booth during a "Trans Youth Prom" event on Capitol Hill in May 2023 in Washington, D.C. (Anna Moneymaker/Getty Images)

Justice

In some states, gender dysphoria is a protected disability — and momentum could be growing

Lawyers and advocates have worked to secure legal acknowledgement of transgender people within the Americans with Disabilities Act for decades.

Orion Rummler

LGBTQ+ Reporter

Orion Rummler headshot

Published

2023-07-20 09:00
9:00
July 20, 2023
am

Share

  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • Email

This Disability Pride Month, we’re telling the untold stories of women, women of color and LGBTQ+ people. Sign up for our daily newsletter.

For nearly six months, Kesha Williams was housed with men in a Virginia prison. Williams, a transgender woman, was denied access to her hormone medication, misgendered and harassed by prison deputies, according to a lawsuit she filed against the county sheriff and detention center staff.

Her ongoing legal fight has created historic precedent: People with gender dysphoria are protected under the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA). The U.S. Supreme Court recently allowed that precedent, first upheld by the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 4th Circuit, to stand. Advocates view that as a hopeful sign in the years-long battle to include trans people in federal disability law. 

The 19th thanks our sponsors. Become one.

Lawyers and advocates have worked to secure legal acknowledgement of transgender people within the ADA for decades. Bias against trans people was baked-in to the ADA at the time of its passage, said Jennifer Levi, the senior director of transgender and queer rights at GLBTQ Legal Advocates & Defenders.  

The ADA excludes disability protections for people with “gender identity disorder” in the same paragraph that it excludes pedophilia and compulsive gambling. When explaining why this exclusion should no longer bar trans people from being protected by the law, legal experts point out that gender identity disorder has not been recognized as a medical condition since 2013. 

However, gender dysphoria — distress experienced by many, but not all, trans people due to their body not aligning with their gender — is a recognized medical condition. It replaced gender identity disorder in the fifth edition of the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders in order to lessen stigma and emphasize that being transgender is not a mental disorder.

  • More Disability Pride Month coverage
    Fannie Lou Hamer speaks to Mississippi Freedom Democratic Party sympathizers outside the Capitol.
  • How Fannie Lou Hamer’s disability informed her fight for voting rights 
  • This longtime disability advocate wants to make every new home ‘visitable’
  • Harris and Buttigieg discuss changing air travel regulations to better accommodate wheelchair users

The ADA prohibits public entities from discriminating against people with disabilities by excluding them from services and programs. In the ADA, disability is discussed as something that keeps people from being able to work or participate in society, Levi said — not because someone is inherently limited, but because they face barriers created by social expectations. For example, the ADA required changes to architecture standards to create accessible buildings and designs that support different kinds of mobility. 

Gender dysphoria keeps people from thriving and participating in society because of the distress and stigma the medical condition causes, and by public institutions not accommodating their needs or providing the gender-affirming care that they need, Levi said. 

The ADA defines a disability as “a physical or mental impairment that substantially limits one or more major life activities of the individual.” As noted by the 4th Circuit, even the sheriff named as a defendant in Williams’ lawsuit does not dispute that gender dysphoria falls within this definition of a disability. The sheriff instead argues that the ADA’s exclusion of “gender identity disorders not resulting from physical impairments” makes William’s case moot. 

But, as the 4th Circuit notes, the ADA must be interpreted as Congress directed in 2008 — as broadly as possible. The court also notes that “nothing in the ADA, then or now,” indicates that gender dysphoria and gender identity disorder can be considered the same condition. 

In her lawsuit, Williams argues that gender dysphoria is a physical phenomenon that cannot be excluded from the protection of federal disability law. The court agrees that Williams has made a sufficient case that her gender dysphoria “result[s] from physical impairments” — and that her need for gender-affirming care to alleviate that distress supports that idea.

“There’s no reason why transgender people can’t and shouldn’t be included,” Levi said. The ADA is “perfectly situated to ensure that transgender people aren’t kept from being included in a whole range of different areas because of the stigma associated with the medical condition that people experience, which is gender dysphoria.”

Activists for transgender rights gather in front of the Supreme Court
Activists for transgender rights gather in front of the Supreme Court in Washington, D.C. in April 2023. (ANDREW CABALLERO-REYNOLDS/AFP/Getty Images)

Levi has been making this argument for a long time: In 2002, she made the first successful legal argument that a trans client should be covered under disability discrimination law in Massachusetts. 

The Supreme Court’s denial to take up Williams’ case could mean that it agrees with the 4th Circuit, or simply that it is not interested in taking up the issue of whether trans people are covered under disability law right now, according to legal experts. Notably, there has not been a split in opinion on this issue among two or more circuit courts, which is a typical incentive for the Supreme Court to get involved. 

In the last few years, the high court has declined to take up challenges to several cases that reinforced protections for transgender people facing discrimination. This trend followed the 2020 ruling in Bostock v. Clayton County, in which the Supreme Court found gender identity to be a protected class of sex. This is possibly because they are abiding by Bostock’s findings that trans people are protected by existing federal laws, said Ezra Ishmael Young, a civil rights lawyer and scholar.

“I think that is good news. I think it signals some confidence to the lower courts that they’re doing a good job with how they’re navigating these various issues,” he said. 

In October 2020, the Supreme Court declined to review a case in which the Idaho Department of Corrections was ordered to provide gender-affirming surgery to a transgender woman. Earlier this year, the high court refused to reinstate the West Virginia ban on transgender students playing school sports that match their gender identity. The Supreme Court also handed a win to Gavin Grimm by declining to hear a Virginia school board’s challenge against allowing trans students to use bathrooms that match their gender identity. It also declined to hear a challenge to a California court decision over a trans patient who was denied hospital care for being transgender.

Although these cases deal with distinct areas of law, they are linked by a common thread: whether transgender people get the same rights as others, Young said. 

Originally aired on July 12, 2023
Disability Pride Month
For Disability Pride Month, we welcomed Raven Sutton, a disability advocate and influencer, and Carson Pickett, a defender for Racing Louisville FC, to discuss the state of people with disabilities in our culture.
Watch Here

Two justices dissented from the decision not to review Williams’ case: Supreme Court Justice Samuel Alito and Justice Clarence Thomas. In that dissent, Alito urges his colleagues to see the question of whether trans people should be covered under disability law as one of “great national importance,” since in his view, it would have “far-reaching and highly controversial effects.” 

“He is deeply worried of what a world looks like in which we recognize the rights of transgender Americans, as they already exist under very old federal laws,” Young said. 

The high court declining to get involved in Williams’ case is a blessing, as it has been in other disability law cases, said Doron Dorfman. 

Dorfman, associate professor at Seton Hall Law School who specializes in disability and health law, pointed to a case two years ago that the Supreme Court declined to review involving a website’s accessibility for blind people. By not getting involved, the high court affirmed a lower court’s ruling and avoided a potentially hostile ruling for disabled people. 

“The Supreme Court denied cert, and everybody was relieved. Because the disability community thought, ‘We don’t want the current makeup of the Supreme Court deciding disability cases right now,’” Dorfman said. 

That 4th Circuit decision in Williams’ favor gave trans people living with gender dysphoria in Maryland, Virginia, West Virginia, North Carolina and South Carolina a powerful protective tool through federal disability law. However, a recent case in the U.S. District Court for the District of Colorado shows how this precedent is being endorsed in other states. 

Colorado, which falls under the 10th Circuit, has no obligation to adopt precedent set by an outside circuit court. However, a federal judge in the case of Griffith v. El Paso County, Colorado — another case involving an incarcerated transgender woman suing a prison for discrimination — agreed with the 4th Circuit that gender dysphoria is protected by the Americans with Disabilities Act. 

“The court is likewise convinced that gender dysphoria is a disability included in the ADA protections, and then he cites Williams, which is a big deal,” Dorfman said. 

However, the judge’s analysis shows that, even if a court accepts this precedent, it doesn’t guarantee that a case will be won. In her lawsuit, Darlene Griffith recounts being assaulted by male inmates and harassed by guards at the county jail, and being denied women’s clothing and female housing. As part of her suit, she accuses El Paso County of disability discrimination against her under the ADA. Those claims, alongside the others in her lawsuit, were dismissed, though Griffith is appealing. The El Paso County Sheriff’s Office declined to comment on the case. 

Notably, the court believes that discrimination based on gender dysphoria violates the ADA and Rehabilitation Act, which prohibits employment discrimination due to a disability. The magistrate judge in the case also finds that Griffith’s gender identity is relevant to needing a reasonable accommodation. 

However, since ADA protections for those with gender dysphoria “is not remotely settled law,” the court ultimately found that Griffith cannot accuse the jail of being “deliberately indifferent” to her disability, or of knowing that it was substantially likely that it was harming her federally protected right. The court also took into account that Griffith had since been moved into a female jail facility. 

In essence, the court said that it wasn’t clear if the prison knew that it needed to accommodate Griffith for her gender dysphoria.

Kevin Barry, associate dean and law professor at Quinnipiac University School of Law, said that the court endorsing gender dysphoria as protected under the ADA — even if it didn’t help Griffith’s case — is important because it underlines that trans people have the right to seek refuge under that law. 

“The reason it’s important is because … if we’re to say that gender dysphoria is excluded, they never get their day in court,” he said. 

Barry expects to see more cases addressing the protection of trans people under federal disability law, and to see more courts revisiting previous decisions. 

“These cases have a way of mushrooming,” Barry said. 

In Zayre-Brown v. The North Carolina Department of Public Safety, a federal judge wrote last September that, due to the 4th Circuit’s unequivocal ruling, “a plaintiff can state a claim for disability discrimination for gender dysphoria as a matter of law.” 

In the meantime, Williams’ case is headed back to district court. The Fairfax County Sheriff’s Office in Virginia, which oversees the detention center that Williams was held in, declined to comment “on particulars of any rulings or nuanced facts” surrounding the Supreme Court declining to review the 4th Circuit opinion in Williams’ favor. 

Williams’ lawyer, employment and civil rights attorney Joshua Erlich, said that Williams “couldn’t be happier” about the outcome of the case so far. She’s eager to get back into court. 

Share

  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • Email

The 19th News(letter)

News that represents you, in your inbox every weekday.

You have been subscribed!

Please complete the following CAPTCHA to be confirmed. If you have any difficulty, contact [email protected] for help.

Submitting...

Uh-oh! Something went wrong. Please email [email protected] to subscribe.

Become a member

Up Next

Trans author, activist, and community organizer Miss Major Griffin-Gracy smiles in her hotel room in Washington, D.C.

LGBTQ+

Stonewall veteran Miss Major is on the road, urging trans people to ‘stand up and fight’

At 80 years old, the legendary trans activist is meeting with White House officials and trans people in New York City, Washington, D.C., and beyond to raise the alarm for transgender rights.

Read the Story

The 19th
The 19th is a 501(c)(3) tax-exempt organization. Our stories are free to republish in accordance with these guidelines.

  • Donate
  • Newsletter
  • Events
  • Search
  • Jobs
  • Fellowships
  • Contact Us
  • About Us
  • Community Guidelines
  • Membership
  • Membership FAQ
  • Ways to Give
  • Sponsorship
  • Privacy
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • Instagram