Skip to content Skip to search

Republish This Story

* Please read before republishing *

We’re happy to make this story available to republish for free under an Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives Creative Commons license as long as you follow our republishing guidelines, which require that you credit The 19th and retain our pixel. See our full guidelines for more information.

To republish, simply copy the HTML at right, which includes our tracking pixel, all paragraph styles and hyperlinks, the author byline and credit to The 19th. Have questions? Please email [email protected].

— The Editors

Loading...

Modal Gallery

/
Donate to our newsroom

Menu

Topics

  • Abortion
  • Politics
  • Education
  • LGBTQ+
  • Caregiving
  • Environment & Climate
  • Business & Economy
View all topics

The 19th News(letter)

News that represents you, in your inbox every weekday.

You have been subscribed!

Please complete the following CAPTCHA to be confirmed. If you have any difficulty, contact [email protected] for help.

Submitting...

Uh-oh! Something went wrong. Please email [email protected] to subscribe.

This email address might not be capable of receiving emails (according to Bouncer). You should try again with a different email address. If you have any questions, contact us at [email protected].

  • Latest Stories
  • Our Mission
  • Our Team
  • Ways to Give
  • Search
  • Contact
Donate
Home

We’re an independent, nonprofit newsroom reporting on gender, politics and policy. Read our story.

Topics

  • Abortion
  • Politics
  • Education
  • LGBTQ+
  • Caregiving
  • Environment & Climate
  • Business & Economy
View all topics

The 19th News(letter)

News that represents you, in your inbox every weekday.

You have been subscribed!

Please complete the following CAPTCHA to be confirmed. If you have any difficulty, contact [email protected] for help.

Submitting...

Uh-oh! Something went wrong. Please email [email protected] to subscribe.

This email address might not be capable of receiving emails (according to Bouncer). You should try again with a different email address. If you have any questions, contact us at [email protected].

  • Latest Stories
  • Our Mission
  • Our Team
  • Ways to Give
  • Search
  • Contact

We’re an independent, nonprofit newsroom reporting on gender, politics and policy. Read our story.

The 19th News(letter)

News that represents you, in your inbox every weekday.

You have been subscribed!

Please complete the following CAPTCHA to be confirmed. If you have any difficulty, contact [email protected] for help.

Submitting...

Uh-oh! Something went wrong. Please email [email protected] to subscribe.

This email address might not be capable of receiving emails (according to Bouncer). You should try again with a different email address. If you have any questions, contact us at [email protected].

Become a member

The 19th thanks our sponsors. Become one.

Justice

Johnny Depp trial unlocks new way for abusers to exert power over survivors, experts worry

Experts say that the amount of attention on this trial is offering abusers a look at a whole new way of potentially exerting power over a survivor.

Johnny Depp's face is illuminated by sunlight while the rest of the image is dark. He is looking down and wears a solemn expression on his face.
Johnny Depp waits during a recess amid his defamation trial against his ex-wife Amber Heard, at the Fairfax County Circuit Courthouse in Fairfax, Virginia. (Jonathan Ernst–Pool/AFP/Getty Images)

Jennifer Gerson

Reporter

Published

2022-05-18 05:00
5:00
May 18, 2022
am

Republish this story

Share

  • Bluesky
  • Facebook
  • Email

Republish this story

Nicole Bedera said she feels “scared” watching the defamation trial brought by Johnny Depp against his ex-wife Amber Heard. 

There has been an extraordinary amount of media attention to the case, which is taking place in a Virginia courtroom, but seemingly all across social media. With the near daily stream of graphic testimony that has emerged from it for weeks on end, Bedera, a sociologist who studies sexual violence, said she can see a new blueprint emerging: Defamation suits could become a way for perpetrators to lock survivors into years of abuse.

“A defamation suit offers a perpetrator a deepening of the power disparities in the relationship and face-to-face contact with a survivor,” Bedera said. “Defamation cases are often a punishment for leaving.” 

The 19th thanks our sponsors. Become one.

Experts say that the amount of attention on this trial is offering abusers a look at a whole new way of potentially exerting power over a survivor. The situation is all the more intensified because of the nature of a defamation suit itself. 

Heard wrote a op-ed for The Washington Post in 2018 in support of the Violence Against Women Act. She explained that her belief in the need for stronger protections for survivors of gender-based violence was personal, writing about the way that coming forward as a survivor of domestic violence had impacted her mental health and professional opportunities. Depp, Heard’s ex-husband, was not named at any point in the op-ed, but it does refer to a time when the couple dominated headlines after Heard had filed for a protective order against Depp in 2016. Depp went on to sue Heard for defamation, saying he had lost acting jobs because of the op-ed and was unable to work after it. 

Historically, saying that you are a survivor of domestic violence has qualified as protected speech, Bedera said. The defamation suit against Amber Heard, however, makes her wonder if this no longer may be the default legal assumption — and what effect that might have. 

  • More from The 19th
    Katie Wussler checks the lot number under a can of baby formula in a storage closet containing baby supplies.
  • New crisis, old inequities: How the baby formula shortage disproportionally hurts low-wage families
  • How did trans people become a GOP target? Experts say it’s all about keeping evangelicals voting
  • Cheri Beasley won North Carolina’s Senate primary. Like other Black women, she laid the groundwork years ago.

“Will this make survivors reluctant to volunteer at a crisis center, to share their story for a non-profit campaign, to warn friends about the perpetrator or ask them to set boundaries with him?” she asked. “I worry survivors will go back to suffering in silence.”

Bedera adds that a defamation suit presumes that an allegation of intimate partner violence is false — despite the fact that false allegations are “incredibly rare.” “False allegations don’t usually look like someone trying to ruin someone else’s life,” Bedera said.

Teresa Drake, the director of the Intimate Partner Violence Assistance Clinic at the University of Florida’s Levin College of Law, also worries that these cases are about “silencing” survivors.

Drake stressed that from a legal perspective, this case is unusual because Heard never once mentioned Depp by name. The presumption is that Depp’s attorneys must present clear and convincing evidence that the op-ed, and only the op-ed, is to blame for their client’s faltering career.

The substantial onus of proving clear and convincing evidence –a standard higher than the preponderance required in most defamation cases because Depp is a public figure —makes her wonder if the case has less to do with defamation and more to do with power.  “Historically, we have seen that women are free to speak their truth — as long as it doesn’t offend a man.”

Drake is also concerned with the trial’s focus on the allegations of what Heard’s and Depp’s abusive behavior during their marriage. This focus strikes Drake as unusual. The case is about determining whether Heard defamed Depp, not whether Heard or Depp were abused. 

Drake shared that since the Depp-Heard trial has begun, a former client of hers has reached out to her: The survivor was granted a protective order several years ago; now, over two years later — and after pleading guilty to a work-related felony — the perpetrator is saying that this ex-wife is to blame for his career ending. Drake said she doesn’t think this timing is a coincidence. 

Amber Heard listens while a person in the foreground speaks.
Amber Heard listens during the $50 million Depp vs. Heard defamation trial at the Fairfax County Circuit Court. (BRENDAN SMIALOWSKI–Pool/AFP/Getty Images)

“This will now cost her tens of thousands of dollars to fight this lawsuit against her, for which there is no evidence — and now her credibility is on the line, too,” Drake said. “This won’t be the last time we see this. This is a tactic of relatively high-functioning abusers who have resources and the energy to muster the court system against a survivor.” 

Drake said that while discussions about domestic violence often focused on the most marginalized survivors, those who come from great means and privilege often face forms of abuse that may look different than publicly held perceptions. 

“When resources are involved — money, popularity — it can act to silence a survivor when there is too much to lose by leaving,” she said. As to the defamation suit, she said, “I think it will say to abusers, ‘Hey — here is a great new tool for your tool belt.’”

Christine M. Scartz, the Jane W. Wilson Family Justice Clinic director at the University of Georgia’s School of Law, said people with more access to wealth and power would gain from the trial and the widespread attention on it. 

Sign up for more news and context delivered to your inbox, daily

You have been subscribed!

Please complete the following CAPTCHA to be confirmed. If you have any difficulty, contact [email protected] for help.

Submitting…

Uh-oh! Something went wrong. Please email [email protected] to subscribe.

This email address might not be capable of receiving emails (according to Bouncer). You should try again with a different email address. If you have any questions, contact us at [email protected].

Preview of the daily newsletter from The 19th

“I promise you that in the demographic I work with, there are abusers out there right now telling victims, ‘I’m going to pull a Depp on you. If you disclose I will sue you,’” she said. “It’s a power and control threat that now has a name attached to it.”

Much of the trial coverage has focused on Depp’s claims that Heard also had hit him, and that he is the victim of intimate partner violence, not her. Heard has testified that when she was physical with Depp, it was only when she felt threatened or when he had physically harmed her in some way first.

Scartz notes that it’s not only abusers currently paying attention to this trial, but law enforcement, prosecutors, defense attorneys and judges. If Heard wins, Scartz said, “I think that will be a signal to judges and lawyers that you should be confident in taking forward imperfect cases and granting relief to people who may not always be all lovely on the outside and consistent in their behavior.” But should Depp win, “because she also fought him a few times, she is not entitled to relief. That’s a very dangerous outcome. If he prevails, it will give decision-makers the ability to abdicate responsibility to decide who the victim is.”

A defamation suit, Drake said, means being entwined in the legal system for “months if not years, worrying about what will happen, spending a huge amount of money on legal representation, having a disruption in your job, facing retaliation from the litigant’s friends and family.” 

Because of the amount of publicity surrounding this case, this now stands to happen to that many more people. Bedera said in her own research with survivors of sexual assault, the numbers of survivors she has spoken to who told anyone about their assault rose astronomically following #MeToo. A fear of a suit like this may make it harder for a survivor “to turn to people they love and trust and need in their life to heal and say, ‘I want to talk to you about something that happened to me.’” 

But, Bedera continued, “Imagine if in trying to talk to all of these people, someone taking the perpetrator’s side says to you, ‘If you keep saying this stuff, he’s going to sue you for defamation.’ I guarantee you that’s happening right now. Or friends and family are saying to someone accused of sexual violence saying, ‘You could sue her.’ I guarantee you that people are saying that right now, all across the country.”

Correction: An earlier version of this article described incorrectly the standard of proof Johnny Depp's lawyers must present.

Republish this story

Share

  • Bluesky
  • Facebook
  • Email

Recommended for you

Women walk on a road at the women-only Taconic Correctional Facility in Bedford Hills, N.Y., Wednesday, March 28, 2012. (AP Photo/Seth Wenig)
Abuse survivors can get shorter sentences in 2 states, but courts are saying no
Gov. Kathy Hochul, wearing red, in 2003
The 19th Explains: What’s next for New York’s Adult Survivors Act on sexual assault
E. Jean Carroll departs the Manhattan Federal Court smiling while surrounded by lawyers and photojournalists.
How a new law allowed E. Jean Carroll to seek justice against Trump years later
Bill Cosby at his sentencing in 2018
‘There is rarely, if ever, justice’: Advocates and survivors seethe after Cosby is freed

The 19th News(letter)

News that represents you, in your inbox every weekday.

You have been subscribed!

Please complete the following CAPTCHA to be confirmed. If you have any difficulty, contact [email protected] for help.

Submitting...

Uh-oh! Something went wrong. Please email [email protected] to subscribe.

This email address might not be capable of receiving emails (according to Bouncer). You should try again with a different email address. If you have any questions, contact us at [email protected].

Become a member

Explore more coverage from The 19th
Abortion Politics Education LGBTQ+ Caregiving
View all topics

Our newsroom's Spring Member Drive is here!

Learn more about membership.

  • Transparency
    • About
    • Team
    • Contact
    • Privacy Policy
    • Community Guidelines
  • Newsroom
    • Latest Stories
    • 19th News Network
    • Podcast
    • Events
    • Careers
    • Fellowships
  • Newsletters
    • Daily
    • Weekly
    • The Amendment
    • Event Invites
  • Support
    • Ways to Give
    • Sponsorship
    • Republishing
    • Volunteer

The 19th is a reader-supported nonprofit news organization. Our stories are free to republish with these guidelines.