Skip to content

Republish This Story

* Please read before republishing *

We’re happy to make this story available to republish for free under an Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives Creative Commons license as long as you follow our republishing guidelines, which require that you credit The 19th and retain our pixel. See our full guidelines for more information.

To republish, simply copy the HTML at right, which includes our tracking pixel, all paragraph styles and hyperlinks, the author byline and credit to The 19th. Have questions? Please email [email protected].

— The Editors

Loading...

Modal Gallery

/

Menu

  • Our Mission
  • Our Team
  • Latest Stories
  • Upcoming Events
  • Contact Us
  • Newsletter
  • Donate
  • Work With Us
  • Fellowships
    • From the Collection

      Changing Child Care

      Illustration of a woman feeding a baby a bottle
      • As climate change worsens hurricane season in Louisiana, doulas are ensuring parents can safely feed their babies

        Jessica Kutz · May 5
      • Supreme Court Justice Samuel Alito argued abortion isn’t an economic issue. But is that true?

        Chabeli Carrazana · May 4
      • Pregnant people are at 'greater risk' in states hit hard by wildfire smoke, air pollution, new report shows

        Jessica Kutz · April 20
    • From the Collection

      Next-Gen GOP

      Illustration of a woman riding an elephant
      • Mayra Flores’ victory set a record for women in Congress. It also reflects the growing visibility of Republican Latinas

        Candice Norwood · June 21
      • A banner year for Republican women

        Amanda Becker · November 11
      • Republican women could double representation in the U.S. House

        Amanda Becker · November 4
    • From the Collection

      On The Rise

      Illustration of three women marching
      • Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson’s swearing in makes history during unprecedented time for the Supreme Court

        Candice Norwood · June 30
      • Biden’s new environmental justice office aims to tackle the health impacts disproportionately faced by people of color

        Jessica Kutz · June 2
      • Jessica Cisneros takes on the last anti-abortion U.S. House Democrat

        Amanda Becker · February 25
    • From the Collection

      Pandemic Within a Pandemic

      Illustration of four people marching for Black Lives Matter with coronavirus as the backdrop
      • Some LGBTQ+ people worry that the COVID-19 vaccine will affect HIV medication. It won’t.

        Orion Rummler · November 23
      • Why are more men dying from COVID? It’s a complicated story of nature vs. nurture, researchers say

        Mariel Padilla · September 22
      • Few incarcerated women were released during COVID. The ones who remain have struggled.

        Candice Norwood · August 17
    • From the Collection

      Portraits of a Pandemic

      Illustration of a woman wearing a mask and holding up the coronavirus
      • For family caregivers, COVID is a mental health crisis in the making

        Shefali Luthra · October 8
      • A new database tracks COVID-19’s effects on sex and gender

        Shefali Luthra · September 15
      • Pregnant in a pandemic: The 'perfect storm for a crisis'

        Shefali Luthra · August 25
    • From the Collection

      The 19th Explains

      People walking from many articles to one article where they can get the context they need on an issue.
      • The 19th Explains: How pregnant people can prepare for a summer of heat waves

        Jessica Kutz · June 17
      • The 19th Explains: How new Title IX guidelines on sexual misconduct may give more help to survivors

        Nadra Nittle · June 14
      • The 19th Explains: How would overturning Roe v. Wade affect IVF?

        Jennifer Gerson · May 27
    • From the Collection

      The Electability Myth

      Illustration of three women speaking at podiums
      • Mayra Flores’ victory set a record for women in Congress. It also reflects the growing visibility of Republican Latinas

        Candice Norwood · June 21
      • Stepping in after tragedy: How political wives became widow lawmakers

        Mariel Padilla · May 24
      • Do term limits help women candidates? New York could be a new testing ground

        Barbara Rodriguez · January 11
    • From the Collection

      The Impact of Aging

      A number of older people walking down a path of information.
      • 'I'm planning on working until the day I die': Older women voters are worried about the future

        Mariel Padilla · June 3
      • Climate change is forcing care workers to act as first responders

        Jessica Kutz · May 31
      • Woman alleges that an assisted living facility denied her admission because she is transgender

        Sara Luterman · November 8
    • From the Collection

      Voting Rights

      A series of hands reaching for ballots.
      • Florida’s redistricting fight continues. The head of the state League of Women Voters talks about what’s at stake.

        Barbara Rodriguez · April 19
      • Women have been sounding the alarm ahead of Texas’ first-in-the-nation primary

        Barbara Rodriguez · February 28
      • LGBTQ+ people of color are at risk from rising voter restrictions as federal protections falter in the Senate, advocates say

        Orion Rummler · January 19

    View all collections

  • Explore by Topic

    • Abortion
    • Business & Economy
    • Caregiving
    • Coronavirus
    • Education
    • Election 2020
    • Elections 2022
    • Environment & Climate
    • Health
    • Immigration
    • Inside The 19th
    • Justice
    • LGBTQ+
    • Politics
    • Race
    • Sports
    • Technology

    View All Topics

Home
  • Our Mission
  • Our Team
  • Latest Stories
  • Upcoming Events
  • Contact Us
  • Newsletter
  • Donate
  • Work With Us
  • Fellowships

We’re an independent, nonprofit newsroom reporting on gender, politics and policy. Read our story.

Support The 19th

As a nonprofit newsroom, members are critical to our sustainability. Your financial support helps make our journalism possible.

Become a Member

Donate to support our mission

The 19th thanks our sponsors. Become one.

A vintage image of Renee Richards and Martina Navratilova holding tennis rackets.
American tennis player Renee Richards (left) and her training partner Martina Navratilova at the tournament in Filderstadt. Navratilova is part of the Women’s Sports Policy Working Group. (Photo by Rzepka/ullstein bild via Getty Images)

LGBTQ+

An elite group tackling transgender sports inclusion has a compromise — and trans people aren’t part of it

LGBTQ+ advocates are slamming a proposal that would force transgender girls to undergo testing to play school sports. 

Kate Sosin

LGBTQ+ reporter

Kate Sosin portrait

Published

2021-02-05 15:39
3:39
February 5, 2021
pm

Share

  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • Email

The biggest red flag for LGBTQ+ advocates was that they couldn’t get in the room. 

On Tuesday, a handful of scholars and elite athletes who formed the Women’s Sports Policy Working Group presented a plan they said would allow transgender youth to participate in school athletics. One by one, leaders from LGBTQ+ rights organizations RSVPed to the news conference and were denied, told that only credentialed media were allowed in. 

The group, which includes tennis legend Martina Navratilova and two-time Olympic gold medalist swimmer Donna De Varona, claims to be the middle ground in a debate consuming state legislatures and agonizing equality advocates: Do transgender girls have an unfair competitive advantage in sports?

The 19th thanks our sponsors. Become one.

LGBTQ+ advocates have promoted policies letting transgender youth play on teams where they are most comfortable, typically with teams of the gender they identify with. Seventeen states and Washington, D.C., have adopted policies that expressly allow trans high schoolers to do just that. 

The working group criticized those policies, saying they allow transgender girls with “unmitigated” testosterone to enter competitions against their cisgender peers. They propose that transgender girls compete with other girls only if they had taken hormones to medically transition and undergo testing. Trans girls who did not qualify would be forced into a third category, with their own heats, games and podiums. 

“There’s an obligation for girls’ sports to develop sporting events with specific accommodations for this group as alternatives to head-to-head competition within girls’ sports,” said Donna Lopiano, founder of consulting firm Sports Management Resources and a member of the working group. 

The proposal was presented as an alternative to an executive order signed by President Joe Biden that directs agencies to enforce the Supreme Court’s June 2020 finding that the Civil Rights Act of 1964, which bans sex discrimination, applies to LGBTQ+ workers. Although Biden’s order does not create policy, his directive does interpret the ruling to extend beyond employment, specifically citing, among other things, sports for children.

How are you going to claim that you’re creating a fair situation here when you’re not involving actual trans athletes?

Chelsea Wolfe

“By stating the administration’s intention to follow Supreme Court precedent and federal law, at core all the newly-elected president did was lay out what the law is and agree, unlike his predecessor, to follow it,” wrote Chase Strangio, the ACLU’s deputy director for trans justice in a blog post. 

But some opponents have accused Biden of “erasing women” in the order. The working group has aimed to position themselves as the solution.

The group’s policy aims to follow testing practices in elite sports. The International Olympic Committee allows transgender athletes to to compete after medical transition, rules based on a study by transgender researcher Joanna Harper, who is a backer of the group, but not a member. Her study looked at eight transgender women runners and found that they were more than 10 percent slower after transitioning with hormones. 

LGBTQ+ advocates and transgender athletes have largely denounced the working group as a disingenuous attempt to exclude trans girls, created without the input of trans athletes. 

“How are you going to claim that you’re creating a fair situation here when you’re not involving actual trans athletes and actual trans people in the discussion?” asked Chelsea Wolfe, a professional BMX freestyle rider who also serves as ambassador for LGBTQ+ sports organization Athlete Ally. “It’s utterly ridiculous.” 

A newsletter you can relate to

Storytelling that represents you, delivered to your inbox.

You have been subscribed!

Submitting…

Uh-oh! Something went wrong. Please try again later.

None of the group’s six members is transgender. On Tuesday, Lambda Legal, the American Civil Liberties Union, Human Rights Watch, the Human Rights Campaign, Athlete Ally and others scrambled to alert the media to what they said was an exclusionary group. But it wasn’t just the makeup of the group, which has been the subject of media praise, that has stirred deep worry among LGBTQ+ equality organizations. 

“It’s just a whole other way to target trans youth,” said Anne Lieberman, director of policy and programs and Athlete Ally. 

Transgender advocates say an untold number of trans kids are already playing on their schools’ teams without issue and that trans athletes come under scrutiny only when they win — a fixation that they say betrays the spirit and intent of sports. 

“The gifts that sports have given me in terms of learning, teamwork, having leadership opportunities, access to a way to consistently move my body to feel connected to my peers, I don’t know where I would be in life if I hadn’t had those experiences growing up,” said Lieberman.

The American Psychological Association recommends policies that allow transgender kids to play sports consistent with their gender identity, and notes that no study has shown that it impacts the nature of the sport. The APA declined to comment on the working group’s specific proposal. 

Inclusive policies became a flashpoint in 2017, when two Connecticut track stars, Andraya Yearwood and Terry Miller, both transgender, landed in the same state. As Yearwood and Miller raced to victory, parents of cisgender girls in the state sued to bar them from competing with other girls, putting a national spotlight on the two athletes. The suits are ongoing.

Working group members say that athletes like Yearwood and Miller should be allowed to compete if they undergo testosterone suppression and hormone replacement therapies. However, the proposal comes alongside a widespread push to ban gender-affirming care for transgender youth, including blockers that allow trans youth to pause puberty. Studies have shown mixed results on the success of hormone therapies leveling the playing field in athletics, but none have been done on transgender kids experiencing puberty. 

Trans youth advocates are hesitant to engage in discussions about medical transition at all. Many trans kids can put off puberty by going on temporary hormone blockers, and a number identity as nonbinary. That information, however, is private, advocates say. They worry that subjecting kids to testing is an unnecessarily invasive hurdle for participation. 

They also argue that no studies have shown transgender teens actually have an advantage and that opponents of inclusion cherry-pick the few kids who win. 

“What they’re asking for as a complete guarantee on winning,” Wolfe said. “And winning is not a human right. Participation in sport is a human right.”

Share

  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • Email

Support The 19th

As a nonprofit newsroom, members are critical to our sustainability. Your financial support helps make our journalism possible.

Become a Member

Donate to support our mission

Up Next

Jaime Gabrielli and her son Justin draped in an LGBTQ flag.

LGBTQ+

A wave of anti-trans bills are hitting statehouses

Experts say that though passing anti-LGBTQ+ bills is a losing battle, some could end up before the Supreme Court.

Read the Story

The 19th
The 19th is a 501(c)(3) tax-exempt organization. Our stories are free to republish in accordance with these guidelines.

  • Donate
  • Subscribe to the Newsletter
  • Attend an Event
  • Jobs
  • Fellowships
  • Contact Us
  • About Us
  • Community Guidelines
  • Membership
  • Membership FAQ
  • Major Gifts
  • Sponsorship
  • Privacy
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • Instagram